7 October 2019

Are Fake News and False Information the Same Thing? Let’s Set the Record Straight.

The term fake news is used far too loosely, often even to describe news published by legitimate sources that may nevertheless contain inaccurate or misleading information.

According to Wikipedia, fake news consists of fabricated, misleading, or distorted information deliberately disseminated through traditional media or the internet with the intention of deceiving the public. Treccani defines it as false news, particularly information circulated online, while Zanichelli describes it as hoaxes or false information spread through mass media.

In our view, fake news and news containing false information are not the same thing, although the two are increasingly treated as interchangeable.

Fake news is deliberately fabricated content designed to damage individuals, institutions, or particular situations. It originates from an unreliable or fictitious source and is intentionally created to spread defamatory, sensational, or misleading claims.

By contrast, news published by a credible, established source that contains false information represents a different—and potentially even more serious—problem.

Fabricated news can often be exposed relatively easily, sometimes through the very internet platforms that helped spread it. False information originating from an authentic, recognized source, however, requires more thorough investigation. It must be challenged through facts, evidence, and independent verification. This makes it particularly dangerous, as the credibility of the source can lend legitimacy to claims that may be inaccurate.

Consider, for example, reports attributing to former US Vice President Joe Biden allegations that Russia was interfering in Italian politics in support of the Five Star Movement (M5S) and the League (Lega). Such reports should not automatically be dismissed as fake news. Rather, they represent claims whose accuracy must be established.

Simply labelling them fake news is not enough. The appropriate response is to call upon the original, identifiable source to substantiate its statements, provide supporting evidence, and allow the facts to be independently verified.

Drawing a clear distinction between deliberately fabricated news and false information published by legitimate sources is essential if we are to address the growing problem of distorted and misleading reporting.

News organizations—including newspapers, television broadcasters, and online news platforms—should devote more time and resources to verifying information, potentially through dedicated daily fact-checking features. Yet uncovering the truth is not always their primary concern. Too often, the pressure to publish and circulate news appears to take precedence over the responsibility to establish its accuracy and authenticity.

Ultimately, the credibility of journalism depends not merely on the authenticity of its sources, but on its commitment to verifying the truth of the information it reports.